- Joy A. Collura and other contributors
InvestigativeMEDIA Five (5) Years Later
Views expressed to "the public at large” and "of public concern"
DISCLAIMER: Please fully read the front page of the website (link below) before reading any of the posts ( www.yarnellhillfirerevelations.com )
The authors and the blog are not responsible for misuse, reuse, recycled and cited and/or uncited copies of content within this blog by others. The content even though we are presenting it public if being reused must get written permission in doing so due to copyrighted material. Thank you.
Independent Public Interest Journalist John Dougherty, InvestigativeMedia (IM), began posting about the June 30, 2013, Yarnell Hill Fire tragedy in July 7, 2013, with an article titled: “Honor guard leads procession of the fallen 19 Granite Mountain Hotshots”
( http://www.investigativemedia.com/honor-guard-procession-of-the-fallen-19-granite-mountain-hotshot-crew/ ). This is the link for the above article.
Other alleged-to-be investigative journalists and websites dealing with wildland firefighting are very restrictive toward those making comments that stray from the standard “Party Line” perspectives. They are blatantly foreclosed from submitting comments, especially if they are counter to the webmaster’s beliefs or “narratives.”
Several of the following experienced Wildland Firefighters and Supervisors (WFs) expressed their sincere (often emotional) views based on their professional experience, training, judgment - and mistakes, including lessons learned. Almost all of these WFs had experienced wildland fire deaths and destruction in varying degrees and some of them are still dealing with the lingering psychological aftermath of these incidents.
And because of that, we ALL grieve for the family, friends, and loved ones, and all others affected by the many facets of the YH Fire tragedy. This includes countless personal tragedies within the main tragedy.
Several of the long-term IM posters include:
Robert [eventually the Second due to there being two Roberts], a former USFS Hot Shot Crew Supt. with over 34 years of wildland fire experience, posted on IM regarding LCES, on July 30, 2013.
Robert (Bob) Powers, a former USFS Hot Shot Foreman who lost his Father in the July 1953 Rattlesnake Fire (CA) on September 2, 2013 posted on the Ten Standard Fire Orders.
Gary Olson, a former USFS Hot Shot Crew Superintendent of two USFS HS Crews and retired as a BLM Special Agent Law Enforcement Officer, posted on September 10, 2013, his emotional views on some of the YH Fire Incident Management Team (IMT) overhead.
Tex (Sonny) Gilligan, aka Charlie, one of the YH Fire hiker / witnesses and a very Irish PhD, hard rock miner, cowboy, logger, “a mucker and a bad motherf**ker,” surveyor, Reno, NV taxi driver, parole officer/outlaw, and former saloon owner, among other things, posted on October 15, 2013, about “getting the facts out there outside of the standard investigation.”
WantsToKnowTheTruth (WTKTT), an anonymous, ingenious poster that has proven to be a huge asset regarding data and metadata, and a “beautiful counsel” to me, posted on October 21, 2013, regarding the inaccuracies and ineptness of the Serious Accident Investigation Team-Serious Accident Investigation Report SAIT-SAIR.
TheTruthWillAlwaysRemainElusive (TTWARE) posted on October 23, 2013, about the shortcomings of the SAIT-SAIR.
Rocksteady, a Canadian WF, posted November 16, 2013, that “the Granite Mountain Hot Shots were ORDERED to move.
Joy A. Collura (me), one of the YH Fire hiker / witnesses, posted on November 18, 2013, about the path that I took on the day of the June 30, 2013, YH fire.
Marti Reed, an ingenious asset with skills in cameras and metadata and a beautiful soul, and I hope when I post my new data she returns to IM. She has been very good to me. ( DECEMBER 22, 2013 AT 7:03 PM )
The Woodsman, another anonymous genius in his own right, with vast insight into human factors and leadership, who really takes these responsibilities seriously.
Methods (Colby Drake) FMO and Silviculture Tech at Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde from Oregon; and part-time poster and author of the 2012 Holloway Fire (NV and OR) Vimeo video subtitled: "We saved the GMHS buggies"
Deborah Pfingston (Andrew Ashcraft's Mother) "Deborah Pfingston says
April 12, 2014, at 8:11 am "Thank you for doing this digging for me. I have [a] theory – of which I have had many but discover they won’t work – I really think there was a back burn set possibly by the trailers. Thoughts!" (emphasis added) The trailers that she refers to are in the Sesame Street area. ( https://www.investigativemedia.com/yarnell-hill-fire-chapter-vi-comments/#comment-24173 )
Otis, the bloke from the UK
Norb Szczurek (aka nick-named - my 'Uncle Norb'), a veteran Lake Tahoe FD (Hybrid) WF,
Diane Lomas, retired AZ schoolteacher, posted about learning answers to what happened at the YH Fire. I am going to finally help you out Diane. Bear with me though.
And even though she may loathe me making the connection to IM, Elizabeth Nowicki, was one of the heaviest and most beneficial contributors with her revealing the USFS Aerial Firefighting Utilization and Effectiveness (AFUE) Study videos and more … and you too Calvin.
Sitta, a great basecamp idea.
Fire20+ (Deanna Thompson) and a friend of Ms. Holly Neill, posted many worthwhile comments and then left and as well Fire20+'s friend and Fire Author, John N MacLean's Research Assistant, Holly Neill. Holly Neill was also on InvestigativeMEDIA even though MacLean told me July 2019 he does not associate with anyone who participates with IM- his own researcher was on IM as a commenter and her friend Deanna Thompson.
In the earliest stages of IM, there were many other trained and experienced WF posters that were openly commenting and discussing the various debatable issues surrounding the deaths of the GMHS and the many competencies and incompetencies of the IMTs and misc. Overhead making (and / or not making) competent and timely decisions.
Regrettably, in the early stages of IM, two posters (NE and NH), critical of these experienced WFs posting views and opinions before the final SAIT-SAIR, basically quashed most of these posters from commenting ever again. The SAIT-SAIR-ADOSH reports have been out for five years now. Unfortunately, this is still happening even today five years later. This trend is thankfully changing because many WFs and IM followers have always disagreed with the report's findings. This especially applies to me - the eyewitness. For easier posting, we have IM and now this non-captcha easy-to-post website.
In a way, all who post on IM are somewhat of a family. And all respectful comments and opinions and views are welcome. In a word, it’s okay to disagree or as the saying goes – at times, “we agree to disagree.”
Investigative journalism in the world has been waning in many places but not here. Five years later, the tenacious InvestigativeMEDIA is still going strong, looking into the contentious and enigmatic YH Fire.
I hope this post honors the 19 GMHS, as well as inspires you to visit the many IM Chapters from the beginning. The IM YH Fire site was constantly visited by SAIT and ADOSH investigators and is still constantly visited to this day by many in the wildland fire industry, even at the highest levels.
In a word, those of us that know there is much more to the story of YH Fire are here to stay. We have made it a lifelong commitment. We feel the SAIT-SAIR had the resources and tools and expertise to do a thorough, professional, and honest investigation, and yet in my eyes, as the eyewitness, they must admit they fell far short in many areas and need much improvement in their investigator skills and integrity. I will begin to show you all that as time allows with this blog and all the UNREDACTED data the alleged "investigators" had at their disposal. Barry Hicks and ADOSH were far better investigators than what was shown by the SAIT.
Dr. Ted Putnam hopes that my web page will open new doors to further information. However, he is steadfastly dug in on the 1949 Mann Gulch Fire in Montana where thirteen WFs died.
Remembering June 30, 2013, and the Yarnell Community and the GMHS
Figure 1. The yellow thumbtack on the Google Earth Image in the upper right identifies the photographer's location for the two photos below this image. Some locals thought the two fire photos below were possibly in the Sesame to The Shrine area. I used Google Earth to mark the photographer's location on the map image below and it is not even near the Fire Break. Source: Google Earth
Figure 2. The photo represents what I have seen in others' actual photos and videos that were taken on June 28-30, 2013, of the fire break area, represented by the green/blue star. These photos and videos exist but have not yet been made public. Source: Google Earth
Figure 3. The photo represents what I have seen in others' actual photos and videos that were taken on June 28-30, 2013, of the fire break area, represented by the green/blue star. These photos and videos do exist; they have not yet been made public. Notice the Fire Break, Shrine, Sesame Street, and "wash area" (chute) drainage alignment directly into the GMHS Deployment Site in the upper right. Source: Google Earth
Figure 4. Photo with metadata overlay of the photo in Figure 5 below. Refer to the photo in Figure 1 at the yellow pushpin in the upper right. Source: Yavapai County Records
Figure 5. Photo of fire behavior in the area of Yarnell looking Westerly right after you leave Yarnell heading toward Peeples Valley, depicted by the yellow pushpin in the upper right of Figure 1. Source: Yavapai County Records
My intent for posting these photos is to show the world what I and others witnessed on June 30, 2013. This is a very sensitive and painful area for me and others. It is very difficult for me to post these because there are so many people that also possess photos and videos of this area and what occurred there. Something serious happened in the Sesame and Shrine area that afternoon that has caused such an odd aftermath that Blue Ridge is not even allowed to be interviewed to this day. I know people have requested to formally meet with some of the men and it is left ignored, and litigation timeframes have since passed.
There is still a lot of confusion and reason to question whether the GMHS Supt. truck, driven by McDonough, and the GMHS buggies accessed Glen Ilah from more towards Sesame Street (witnessed by several locals), and NOT over by the Shrine. We KNOW they went IN that way, so the confusion is where did they come OUT.
Consider now some video Snippet images of YH Fire aggressive fire behavior, BRHS Supt truck, and GMHS Crew Carriers. These photo Snippets from the two videos (below) show the vehicles coming out from the Sesame Street area, which is contrary to the SAIT-SAIR, indicating the vehicles that came out of The Shrine area, which is the opposite side of Yarnell. Details are provided in each Figure caption.
Figure 6. June 30, 2013, YH Fire aggressive lateral fire behavior (unknown area and time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.a. June 30, 2013, YH Fire aggressive lateral fire behavior (unknown area and time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.b. June 30, 2013, YH Fire aggressive lateral fire behavior (unknown area and time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.c. June 30, 2013, YH Fire aggressive lateral fire behavior (unknown area and time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.d. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing BRHS Supt. truck exiting from Glen Ilah area near Ranch House restaurant with intense fire behavior and dark smoke in the background (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.e. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing BRHS Supt. truck with GMHS Crew Carrier following, exiting from Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.f. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing GMHS crew Carrier exiting from Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.g. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing two GMHS Crew Carriers exiting the Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.h. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing three WFs or FFs working along an aggressive fire behavior area (unknown area and time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.i. Video link provided because the URL would not post as a video using the Wix upload method and showed an error message instead. Granite Mountain Hotshot and the only survivor of the fire !!!! video ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=db_5hae9FUo ) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.j. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing GMHS Crew Carrier exiting the Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.k Honoring the Granite Mountain 19. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing two GMHS Crew Carriers exiting the Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube, Eye of the universal world
Figure 6.l. Honoring the Granite Mountain 19. June 30, 2013, YH Fire (Snippet), showing two GMHS Crew Carriers exiting the Glen Ilah area (unknown time) Source: YouTube
Figure 7. Granite Mountain Hot Shots Honored 6 Years After Yarnell Fire Source: YouTube
The locals that stated they saw them exit from Sesame is contrary to the SAIT-SAIR that they exited from the Shrine. So, my red flag is WHY did they exit from the longer route out from the Shrine area when they were positioned out past Sesame Street? I have to ask, what was occurring out there in the Sesame Street area at the time?
The entire YH Fire event has traumatized me and so many others. So many are fearful of what they experienced, what they saw, and what they possess. In a word, they have simply given up, they are disgusted with the whole thing to the point of apathy. Because of what some witnessed that day, they will not even return to their properties ever again. Some have even died because of the stresses of what they experienced and because none of what they saw that day was ever addressed in the SAIT-SAIR. It was as if it never happened. These "others" have allowed themselves, or worse yet, they have convinced themselves to no longer care about the entire YH Fire debacle.
When I took a GMHS loved one (parent) directly to the person who had a solid credible testimony of his YH Fire experience who lost his home, who was sitting on the knoll near the Sesame location with others, and when he went to shake his hand this eyewitness man's body gave out and collapsed to the ground in the depth of deep tears and he told this parent, I am so sorry for the loss of your son. This moment trying to bridge loved ones to the eyewitnesses halted because of the depth of emotions. We left the area and there was another eyewitness who also had a similar moment, so I decided to bridge the loved ones to the actual eyewitnesses who were failing in processing data to one another and it became just too sensitive.
Therefore, I relate to this because even posting all this is way too overwhelming for me.
It is my humble opinion that the YH Fire SAIT, self-proclaimed "Human Factors Lead Investigator" Brad Mayhew should have been the one trying to bring out the human factors' professional judgments and conclusions long ago. ( contributing author )
We owe it to ourselves, the men that died that day, and every future WF to reveal and share this critical information for the purpose of wildland fire lessons learned.
If anyone viewing these pictures recognizes the location (i.e. telephone poles)in Figure 5., please add your comments. Thank You.
Some of the current thoughts of the IM participants about the YH Fire and 5 years later are addressed here by IM poster Woodsman on June 29, 2018, at 6:38 pm: http://www.investigativemedia.com/please-begin-yarnell-hill-fire-chapter-xxvi-here/#comment-474623
UPDATES: Minor spelling, punctuation, caption line spacing, and grammar corrections and edits throughout the post, added Figures 6, 6.a-l. video Snippets, and Figure 6.h. video link provided because the URL would not post as a video using the Wix upload method and showed an error message instead. Granite Mountain Hotshot and the only survivor of the fire !!!! video Figure 7. video (Granite Mountain Hot Shots Honored 6 Years After Yarnell Fire). (June 26, 2021, at 10:22 PM)
webmaster reviewed page last: 7-19-18 1:45pm
this page last: 2-1-2021 3:17PM
(Blog Was On Pause since 1-27-21- Glad blog was on pause - there was missing content and it was all moved around and broken links.) (JC)
#wildlandfire #Yarnellfire #GraniteMountainHotShot #InvestigativeMEDIA #Independent Public Interest Journalist John Dougherty #Robert [eventually the Second due to there being two Roberts], a former USFS Hot Shot Crew Supt. with over 34 years of wildland fire experience #Robert (Bob) Powers, a former USFS Hot Shot Foreman who lost his Father in the July 1953 Rattlesnake Fire (CA) #Gary Olson, a former USFS Hot Shot Crew Superintendent of two USFS HS Crews and retired as a BLM Special Agent Law Enforcement Officer, #WantsToKnowTheTruth (WTKTT), # TheTruthWillAlwaysRemainElusive (TTWARE), #Tex (Sonny) Gilligan, aka Charlie, one of the YH Fire hiker / witnesses and a very Irish PhD, hard rock miner, cowboy, logger, “a mucker and a bad motherf**ker,” surveyor, Reno, NV taxi driver, parole officer/outlaw, and former saloon owner, among other things, #Rocksteady, a Canadian WF, #Joy A. Collura (me), one of the YH Fire hiker / witnesses, #Marti Reed, an ingenious asset with skills in cameras and metadata and a beautiful soul, #The Woodsman, another anonymous genius in his own right, with vast insight in human factors and leadership, who really takes these responsibilities serious, #Otis, the bloke from the UK, #Norb Szczurek (aka my' Uncle Norb'), a veteran Lake Tahoe FD (Hybrid) WF, #Diane Lomas, retired AZ schoolteacher, #Elizabeth Nowicki, #Calvin, #Sitta, #Fire20+ (Deanna Thompson), #Holly Neill, #John N MacLean's Research Assistant, #SAIT-SAIR-ADOSH reports, #Human Factors Lead Investigator" Brad Mayhew, #Methods (Colby Drake) (hashtags)
Post Number Three
© (All Rights Reserved) ( www.yarnellhillrevelations.com ) Disclaimer Copyright 2018
If you right click and click "print" and save as PDF- 25 pages.
Update October 19th, 2021 1:15am- Fred J. Schoeffler has my full permission to use any and all content from "InvestigativeMEDIA Five (5) Years Later?" on his new "Project 10 and 18 United" / "Project 10 and 18 International" blog he is creating.- Joy A. Collura
6-26-22 3:21pm Update: Home | Project 10 & 18 (project10n18.org)
Post Number One: Did the late afternoon, June 30, 2013, Sesame Street and The Shrine fire behavior/smoke plumes influ (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Two: Are These Possible Indications of YH Fire Burnout Ops In The Peeples Valley Area On June 30, 2013? (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)
Post Number Four: What Lessons Have We Really Learned About The June 30, 2013, Yarnell Hill Fire? (yarnellhillfirerevelations.com)